Hey guys so I will just start us off. I dont get how Lizbeth is on top of the charts??? I mean for 1 less damage, you get lulabee, which is FAR more stable than Lizbeth. I know, different clans, but Ulu is not that bad by themselves. + there are many replacements, and Lizbeth is what, like 60k? this is ridiculous.
I think Dorian is quite borderline as well, Uppers can still do pretty well without him. Herman, Hefty, even Lady are all replacements for Dorian, i mean i know he is strong against SoA, but thats it!. Herman is actually more threatening than Dorian in many matchups minus GHEIST/Roots.
Jose Star and Nimestiec are mostly played at 0 pillz to waste the opponent's pills. Therefore that 2 more atk reduction is around equal to that 1 damage.
Rubie and Oxen?
Rubie's 5 power makes her not so good. If you lead with her, they won't have any trouble beating her. Even if they lead, you'll have to overpill to beat them.
Oxen is weak to SOA. If Oxen was such a good card, why is Ngrath barely used? You might say the two atk reduction points but Ngrath has a lower min.
Would you rather have a draw of Romana Tremorh Qubik Eebiza?
or Rubie, Oxen, Kazayan, Nellie/Maurice?
They have around the same raw power, but the Junkz one is more stable and doesn't suck against soa or sob.
And no, I'm not a FPC user. I play clans all over the place but mostly Pussycats, Montana, All Stars, and Roots. (for elo that is)
I have said that Diana is Kazayan with one more power. Yet, I have not said that she was straight up better than him. PC are all reducers. If you are onto Mono PC, you would never throw away Diana just as a reducer. The reducing capabilities of Diana is more like a back-up just in case you lose.
Bad damage on hand is a very bad description of an average PC hand. With their staples/semistaples: Noemi, Clover, Diana, Leela/Charlie is this low damage? The ok damage clan members: Ivana/Ella/Wanda, Jayzel, Malicia. A better description of the PC clan is that its hard to get the dmg in.
Lizbeth is OP, but just borderline she's basically a Dorian or Troompah but worse, Very weak against SOA and unlike Troompah she also looses her damage so she becomes a 2* against Soa. I too am very suprised that she's been banned more often than Beeboy, Trrompah, Dorian and Ongh.
Well if you compare her with Dorian she packs one more power but has a greater weakness. Dorian is impervious to SOA.
And if you compare against FPC, Freaks, Junta, PC, Skeelz, Berzerk, Roots, Ghiest, Jungo, Vortex all of them have a harder time beating Dorian than Lizbeth, because of Dorian's bonus. So actually against these clans Dorian is more OP than Lizbeth.
IMO if Lizbeth is OP so is Dorian
Now the interesting bit is that against other attack manipulator clans Dorian is less powerful and Lizbeth is better against Montana, Uppers, Junkz, Sakhrom, Sentinel. In Elo most players use Montana Uppers and Junkz. Thus since Lizbeth for them is OP they vote against her more and thus she gets banned more often.
Another reason is that Lizbeth is singled out the most pwerful in Piranas. Unlike in Jungo people have to choose between Troompah and Ongh and in Roots they have to choose between Gertjan, Tuck and Gretchen so the votes are divided etc.