Seeing as this thread is more generalized i think it would do better in the strategy and tactics:general
Sasha (mono-only), Redra, Belle, Liam, Milton, Otto, Jessica, Wilhem, Todd, Anton
Chiara, Sandro (mono-only), Andy Ld/Lorna/Snowflake, Praxie/Zeke, Cley/Danae, Deebler, Drake, Chwing, Saho
Some (as noted by the "/" depend on the deck and what your preference is though they are in order w/ considering preference
Dr Falkenstein, Greem, Belgosi, Manfred, Jay, Corvus, Carter, Damian, Aigwon. Aigwon Noel
Caelus Cr (if he comes is ever unbanned), Michael, Tomas, Eloxia, Logan, Dwan, Aylen
Well, I can accurately tell you ELO: (Mono-clan)
Hawkins, Tula, Amiral Coco, Puff, Spycee, Kalder, Dante, rest are useless.
Taljion, Ector, Tyd, Baba, Andsom, Rhed Cr, rest are really, really, REALLY unplayable.
Scubb, Raeth, Kristin, Sheryl, Sting, Coleridge, Katan
Selma, Dahlia, Lizbeth, Bloodh, Ahkab, rest are not worth it.
I actually give Snowflake like second priority....
Liam is better than Belle Skeelz REALLY lack SoA
wow Aylen is really powerful i think she comes second or third Logan just sucks
Amiral Coco/ Puff > Tula
for 3 star i actually think its worth mentioning Greesh a REALLY underrated card very good for dealing damage (something Piranas lacks)
hahaha might be just me but after tan man i go with Oraya that damage is really appealing
5 stars are all debatable but Selma does not come first (personally i really like Bloodh) but Lizbeth and dalhia both provide better round- winability capabilities
Tula>Puff - 4 damage is more than 2, she's a good counter to Toro/Robb etc. Even though the 9 power might seem better, the 2 damage isn't worth it. Protower and SOA destroy Tula, most times you can play her so she doesn't face it.
Selma>Lizbeth - Selma has a lot of damage, *AND* pill manip. Lizbeth has strong power and damage, but fails miserably to SOA. 7/7 vs. 6/4 against SOA, I'd definately take Selma.
Selma>Bloodh - Bloodh is a nuke, but since theres no other cards that gap really well in Piranas, you most likely have to win 3/4 rounds, and +3 life doesn't do that.
Selma>Dalhia - Dahlia is only effective in the first rounds, and she doesn't help with the damage problem of the Piranas. Selma can be used any round, and has more damage.
Well for elo ill throw out some Uppers i suppose
Jose Star Gail Ld Wendel Bianca Samantha Jonas Colin Mickey T
Harold Oxen Burt Frankie Hi Rubie Lydia Pallack Stanford
Nellie Kazayan Maurice Jody Wayne Stark Beetenka
Dorian Hefty/Herman(these 2 really boil down to preference) Lady Glenn Jeeves
for ELO imo hope it helps
lets try to stick to ELO cards guys since this is the ELO forum