Melinda: Not the worst 5* ever made but when you compir her to the other Berzerk 5*s shes not that good. She could be used in a Berzerk T2 deck though. 6/10
Jeffrey: I quite like Jeffrey, Lola is better but i would use him over Kawamashi. 7/10
Carlito: Anuther card which isn't bad just not as good as the other cards in the clan. 6/10
Arnie: He is quite good but i would use Bryan over him 8/10.
Melinda - Yes she does have 6 base damage and 7 Power but Melinda's ability isn't quite upto snuff if she has +3 life she would be better even though she'd be the same as Oren of The Freaks and Bloodh of The Piranas. Lola is the only other Berzerk with the ability Defeat + X Life but she recovers 3 life and Her Power isn't as high as the Other 3* Berzerk
Jeffrey - It is always good to have another SoB because with Taylor it is really difficuilt to fit a 5* in a T1 deck although it is not Impossible But with 7/3 stats Jeffrey will be seen in Mono Berzerk decks but SoB is a good ability to have don't get me wrong but Lola is Like a DR, Kawamashi has Attack manipulation, Vivian has Unstoppable Damage and Norman has 8 Power
Carlito - Not the best Bangers card but Not the Worst either he will replace Garrik but Loocio will still be best 3* Bangers But Carlito would be a good beginers cards sort of like Pallack but he is a Uppers while Carlito is Bangers
Arnie - He replaces almost every 4* La Junta yes his damage is 4 which is not as high as La Junta 4* Like Bryan who has 5 damage but his Power is excellent at 8 With Chiro being The only other 4* La Junta with 8 Power But she is restricted to mono and you can Put alot of Pillz on him aslong as he doesn't encounter SoA
Melinda:5*, so definitely not best for elo. 7 power(decent enough) and 6 damage(8 with bonus... Sorta). This card is pretty good compared to what we already have for Berzerk. I personally dislike how all this card has to win is it's power. Although not a good one, the defeat + 2 life compensates for this, it isn't very good balance. Great way to start a fight, but useless in almost all other areas.
Carlito: this card is simple, if you plan on elo decks, you might be interested. If your looking for a card that blocks damage reduction, hes the right card. I prefer Kluwn and some others, but hes a good addition.
Jeffrey: i dislike him, as he has decent power, poor damage, semiuseful ability, and his bonus to compensate for the damage. Better than some 3* now for Berzerk, but we should expect better ones.
7.3/10 for now. Most likely 4/10 later
Arnie: best in the release. La Junta bonus makes a gain if you win, relying on power and ability. 8 power can easily be worked with. La Junta is known to have good 2 *, so he fits in elo and t2.
Stats with bonus are 8,6. Ability makes him good finisher( so if your opponent has 6 life, go all out on him. You will see that if he wins, its a ko, if he loses he regains pillz, making just about his only weakness power/attack reducers, and damage reducers. Manouver past these and you have Arnie as a top ranked card.