@post 63 -Bakuryu
"But there's no such thing as a 50/50 card."
There are situations where you are forked, not 50/50'd. Forking is when you play your cards in a correct order so your opponent can't counter you. A 50/50 is when you play a card that says, "You have to perfect pill me, or I win the game" as early as round 1-2, possibly even 3.
In the situation you provided, Player 2 wins, no matter what. There is no 50/50 situation there.