Well, Guedes, some ELO bans are unfair (see Arno). On the other hand... DERBY QUEEN BANNED? most of the loops with her involve El Broken-o and Kinicha---I mean instant ragequit. Those cards need to be banned because the loops and massive attack. But Arno/Derby Queen? Roots are barely playable and DQ is situational and sometimes predictable.
@TGAP-Trixie: I really don't want Bonnie Ld in Elo at all she is too powerfull for that the point I'm trying to make with Smokey Cr is he is not super over powered and there are other Elo legal 3 stars who are arguably better than Smokey Cr. The point of switching around Elo Perma-Bans should be to perma ban overpowered cards and unban cards that are not powerful enough to warrant a perma ban but are banned anyway.
i actually agree with you on the dont let all players vote for staffbanns subject.
people are gonna vote for their favourite clans op cards to unban
and ban those cards that cause their favourite clan trouble
also they dont realise things like if you unban robb cr and ban saki you are making it harder for new players
i voted kinichaw mechakolos(though id rather ban xu52) fuzz cliff and eddie to go
and wee lee to come back
ur banned almost all poison ability cards and eddie is very similar so why isnt he banned or switched with wee lee yet?
Saki was made to substitue robb cr
Qubik was made to sub Rowdy
Flora was made to sub arno
Sue was made to sub Lea
Many more sub cards were made to balance a clan, pretty sure of that. Some player comments are for the sake of their favorite clan, comment wisely. I'm not even making comments dorian to be back because he's my favorite card
I disagree with roots being unplayable tho, top tier elo players use them anytime. You want to know some clan unplayable? Look at Sentinel lads, Luke didn't sub Lehane for Kate's sake. If the staff really want deck varieties they should consider unbanning lehane. I agree with the lea elvira swap for sledge cliff. At least double olding can be dealt because of smaller life gapping.
@troll4663 i agree with you completely, i was being sarcastic on derby queen, i dont think she deserves a ban (neither do arno), but noctezuma, el divino and kinichaw certainly deserve it. Maybe even el gascaro, but i would let him for players ban vote decision.
@post 45 I am not in favor of making any exchanges with rescue banned characters and there hasn't been any talk about an exchange. Rescue have gotten very strong. The bans that are suggested at the time seem very fair. I do support your previous suggestion on banning jautya,but then a character as to come up as a substitute. As for the Lehane issue, let's face it lehane might not be like freaks 2 star cards(which can create a great lifegap) but she is a powerhouse
I believe that after the bans-unbans arno is bound to come back,Lou should stay where she is at. In the meantime I suggest that similar cards to Lou get banned like XU52 and Fuzz,since they tend to create 50 50 matches. As for the uppers,I do believe that Herman deserves to be banned along with Kazayan. Beetenka,Maurice and Nelie are all very usable. Additionally I suggested that Jean get's banned. Jungo got Pegh,Mindy plus a few more. Jean gave too much power to the Jungo,hence every week Ongh is not banned we are bound to see the majority of UR using Jungo.
All in all the characters that the staff has put on the list to be banned seems very precise Those are the characters that plagued ELO plus maybe a few others.
If oshitsune is going away,which is imminent to happen(the character is clearly overpowered) I suggested that Ghumbo makes a comeback,the reasons why, are again on oshitsune's english comment section.
Agree with Icarus.
Same when Mona and Avola were staff banned: people said montana was dead but a few months later Waller came. Montana isn't the clan it used to be with Mona and Avola but they aren't dead anymore.
I think the same will happen with [for example] Uppers when Herman gets banned or Piranas when Lizbeth gets banned. Or they just get a banned card back (for example Ulrich for Lizbeth)
I think when Campbell and Cliff/Sledg gets banned, they get Lea of Elvira back and when XU52, Mechakolos or Leviatonn gets banned they will get Bristone or Dolly back
1. Jean? Really? The reason that they're played is because of ongh not jean. Which you said..
2. Why does juatya deserve a ban? Nyema is the same card without attack manip. (Not the best comparison but I don't see him as OP) Is it just because of the combo with uranus?
3. How is oshi OP? He's great in DM but in elo he's easy to play around. I'm using him this week for the little I've played and for every match he's been more of a burdain then anything. Soa, attack manip, all stars kill him. He's a great card and can be hard to deal with sometimes but he isn't OP.